Print this guide
    A Reading Group Guide to

    A Shiloh Christmas

    By Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

     

    About the Book

    Marty and his beagle, Shiloh, have been inseparable since Marty rescued Shiloh from Judd Travers’s cruel treatment. Anywhere Marty goes, Shiloh’s by his side, and Marty couldn’t be happier about that. Even Judd has changed his ways and is trying to live a better life, to be a better person.

    When a fire breaks out near Judd’s property, Marty risks his life to save Judd’s dogs, but the dogs run away after they are set free from the danger of fire. As Marty and Shiloh search for them, Shiloh also goes missing, and Marty is beside himself. Then, townsfolk start blaming Judd for the fire! With Christmas just around the corner, Marty tries to remain hopeful—that the Christmas spirit will bring love and generosity to his town, and Shiloh home.

    Discussion Questions

    1. Many people in the community neither like nor approve of Judd Travers even though he is trying to change. How does Judd prove to the townspeople that he has changed?

    2. Judd, Marty, and Rachel have all been influenced by their parents. How has the parental influence felt by each character shaped that character’s life and personality?

    3. Marty thinks Dara Lynn is exaggerating when she talks about Ruthie’s father and the punishment he administers. Do you agree? How is exaggerating different from lying?

    4. What is David and Marty’s reaction when they find Rachel locked in the shed? How do they respond? How does their perception of Rachel change as a result of the incident?

    5. What do Marty’s parents think of Pastor Dawes? How do they feel about his sermons? What do they learn about his personality from what others have told them?

    6. Why are Marty’s parents concerned about Rachel and Ruthie? What occurs to lead Marty’s parents to conclude that the girls are being abused by their father?

    7. Who are the people Marty trusts to answer his why questions? How do the answers he receives from them help Marty grow wiser?

    8. Why does Marty put his life in danger to save Judd’s dogs? Why does Marty want to tell his parents? How do Marty’s parents react to his confession?

    9. Why are people in the community convinced that Judd started the fire even after the investigation proves he is innocent? How does Judd react to their rudeness?

    10. Why does Rachel run away? What does Judd do and say to help restore her to her family?

    11. What parenting advice do Marty’s parents give to the pastor and his wife? How does their advice help the pastor become a more loving father?

    12. How does Doc Murphy encourage Marty’s dream of becoming a vet? How does Dr. Collins encourage Marty’s dream?

    13. What is ironic about the way people judge Judd and the preacher? Of the two, who is the kinder person? What evidence in the novel supports your choice?

    14. What does Marty learn about people and life as a result of the biography and autobiography assignment Mr. Kelly gives his students?

    15. When Marty’s dad talks to Judd about the preacher coming to Christmas dinner, Marty says, “Talk about smooth.” What does Marty mean?  How does his dad convince Judd to come for dinner?

    16. When the preacher sees Becky climb into her dad’s lap, why does he cry? How is this the beginning of change in the way the preacher treats his daughters?

     

    Enrichment Activities

    Water, Water Everywhere

    Doc Murphy says, “Since the world began, not a single drop of water has been added to the earth, or a single drop taken away.” What does this mean? Ask students to investigate this statement and to prove that it is either true or false. Have students support their answer with factual evidence and a graphic display to explain the water cycle. Students may also research challenges or obstacles to continued fresh water access for future generations. Have students add their additional findings to their displays. 

    Faith to Believe

    Marty struggles with his faith and understanding about God because what he hears about God often contradicts what he experiences. Working in small groups, ask students to find passages in the book where Marty questions who God is and how God responds to his people. Then, based on the passages, ask them to write a statement from Marty’s point-of-view about his belief about God and how it’s evolving.

    The Good and the Bad

    Every main character in A Shiloh Christmas could be categorized as “good” or “bad.” Brainstorm with the students a list of characteristics for each category. Ask students to place each of the characters in one of the categories and to support their choice with evidence from the book. If a character changes from one category to another, students should also state the event that occurred to change the character’s life. Can people be only all-good, or only all-bad? Can people have characteristics that appear in both categories? Is this OK? Discuss with your students how most individuals are a product of their experiences, and that oftentimes, people can exemplify traits deemed as good and bad during their life.  

    Have students select one of the characters and create a character autobiography, told in first person that helps explain how that character exemplifies good or bad characteristics, or both. Have students share their character autobiographies in small groups. 

    Taking Care of Animals

    Clearly, Marty loves animals: he saves Shiloh from abuse, he works for Dr. Collins, and he risks his life to save Judd’s dogs. His dream to become a vet will be expensive and require hard work and dedication. With a partner, ask students to research colleges near West Virginia that offer veterinary degrees and then prepare a video explaining the following: the prerequisite course requirements, the cost of the degree, the years required, and other pertinent information a perspective student would need to know. Students can present their videos to the class.

    Child Abuse or Discipline?

    Marty and his parents suspect that Rachel and Ruthie are being abused by their father, but they are unsure about how to handle the situation. Ask students to research the definition of child abuse and to determine if the punishment the pastor gives his daughters can be considered abuse, or whether it is discipline. Then ask students to write their opinion and support it with facts they have gleaned from their research. Have students share their opinion papers in small groups.

    Find Shiloh

    After reading A Shiloh Christmas, try to find the largest map possible of Tyler County, West Virginia and locate the community of Shiloh. Look for all the cities or towns mentioned in the book. Some include: Parkersburg, Sistersville, Friendly, etc. Can you find any of the roads and creeks Marty talks about in the story?

     

     

    Guide written by Susan Geye, Library Coordinator, Everman ISD,  Everman,TX.

    This guide has been provided by Simon & Schuster for classroom, library, and reading group use. It may be reproduced in its entirety or excerpted for these purposes

More Books From This Author

Zack and the Turkey Attack!
Our Story Begins
The Shiloh Collection
The Alice Collection/The Middle School Years

About the Author

Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
Photo Copyright: Gilbert

Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

Phyllis Reynolds Naylor has written more than 135 books, including the Newbery Award–winning Shiloh and its sequels, the Alice series, Roxie and the Hooligans, and Roxie and the Hooligans at Buzzard’s Roost. She lives in Gaithersburg, Maryland. To hear from Phyllis and find out more about Alice, visit AliceMcKinley.com.

BECOME A FAN

Explore

CONNECT WITH US