"Memorable birds from fiction and film are now joined by a new flock of feathered friends. The compilation takes the reader on riveting macabre flights of fantasy that address winged victories and human fallacies."
– Diabolique Magazine
"Datlow taps into the spooky and sometimes unsettling aspects of the bird kingdom. A solid selection of dark fantasy and horror pieces, many of which possess a more literary tone, opting for psychological and subtle terror over blood and gore. A thought-provoking exploration of the theme."
– Publishers Weekly
"This haunting anthology presents an amazing array of writers who use avian tales to touch upon the shadows and light that exist in human lives. Aficionados of dark fantasy and horror will appreciate."
– Library Journal
"The vastly different ways the terror presents itself, and the distinct storytelling styles and pacing more accurately reflect how deep seated and pervasive our fear of avians truly is. A volume to satisfy dark fantasy and horror readers alike."
"A tightly focused collection of short stories that is perfect for those with a fascination for the disquieting aspect of the avian, as well as for readers who enjoy a few supernatural thrills with their crime. The long shadow of dark wings reaches across each page, making this anthology essential reading for the horror/crime completest."
– Criminal Element
"With this anthology, Datlow has further cemented her reputation as an editor with an eye for quality and her finger on the pulse of the horror genre. Here she has assembled a stellar line-up of some of the very best writers in the field today, every one a published and accomplished master of the craft. With such contributors there is no question that the anthology would be good. But under the stewardship of Datlow, the stories take wing and fly."
– This is Horror
"Black Feathers is another triumph for this talented editor and highly recommended for its diverse and skilled contributors. It will definitely cause you to think twice the next time you see a flock of birds soaring through the sky or hear their songs outside your window."
"With concepts as high-flying, and prose as graceful, as the birds around which it is themed, Black Feathers is a well-conceived and -executed anthology, and a showcase of some of the finest speculative and weird fiction of 2017."
– New York Journal of Books
"Datlow’s latest collection could be the one to engage teens in the short story format. Fans of Edgar Allan Poe’s work or Alfred Hitchcock’s The Birds will find these more contemporary tales equally compelling. The volume as a whole is a creative writing teacher’s dream. This riveting anthology should amply reward those who love eerie fare."
– School Library Journal
"A masterful presentation of dark avian-themed shorts. At its very worst, it is good, more often it’s great, at other times it is superb. Entertaining on numerous levels: endearing, suspenseful, beautiful, painful, incredible."
– Unnerving Magazine
"Good reads in a disturbing way. I recommend Black Feathers for fans of weird fiction."
– SF Crowsnest